Staff recruiting and HR for Catholic parishes and schools

Order frees good people for the mission.

Peace through order, for Catholic parishes and schools.
  • One flat fee, quoted up front
See how a search works →

Request a call

Thirty minutes, no cost. You'll leave with a plan for the role, whether you hire us or not.

What the empty seat costs

The salary you're saving isn't a savings.

Someone puts in their notice. It can take 45+ hours to recruit and onboard a replacement. Meanwhile their work doesn't stop. It moves.

  • Someone else is doing two jobs.Usually your most dependable person. They won't complain. They'll get tired, and tired people leave.
  • The mission waits.The calls that don't get returned and the new families that don't get followed up with may be a missed opportunity.
  • The rushed hire costs the most.When the pressure gets high enough, the first acceptable person gets the job. Six months later you're hiring for it again.

What has this opening cost so far?

Two numbers. No email needed.

150hours

That's close to 4 full work weeks your staff has given to one empty seat.

You may be thinking
“A parish has no business paying someone to hire a staff member.”

It's a fair thought. You're spending donated money and you answer for every dollar.

Here's the comparison. Recruiting agencies commonly charge a quarter to a third of a new hire's first-year pay. We charge a flat fee, and you know the number before we start.

What you get

One complete search. Nothing left for you to chase.

We recruit for every role on your staff. Each search runs the same way, so nothing gets missed and nobody has to invent the process.

A team kickoffYour leaders in one room before anything is posted. They say what a strong hire looks like, so they back the person who's chosen.Why it matters: people support what they helped shape.
A written search planThe role, the pay, the interview panel, and the dates, on one page you sign.Why it matters: no surprises in week six.
The search itselfThe job description, the posting, every applicant email, screening calls, and reference checks. You get a short update every Friday. If you already use Paylocity Recruiting and Onboarding, we work inside your system.
Organized interviewsA trained panel and a scorecard. Each person scores alone before anyone compares notes. We group finalist interviews into one day whenever possible.Why it matters: structured interviews pick better than gut feel.
The offerThe background check request, a personal call to your candidate, and a written offer letter.
The first 90 daysA plan for the new hire's first three months, a check-in call at day 30, and a review at day 90. Onboarding help is available if you want us to run it.Why it matters: most hires that fail, fail early.
What it asks of you

You make the decisions.

Approve the role and the wage. Supply the interview panel. The hiring manager makes the final call.

What we handle

We carry the work.

Everything else. If you're wondering whether something is on your list, it isn't.

More than a filled seat

Every search leaves the role in order.

When the search is over, you keep more than a new employee. You keep the things that make the job clear, for this person and the next one.

A current job descriptionThe role is written down as it is today. For many parishes and schools, that's the first time in years.
A scorecardA plain picture of what doing this job well looks like. It becomes the review form.
A named ownerOne person is responsible for the hire and for onboarding. No more "I thought you had it."
A 90-day planYour new hire knows what's expected from the first morning.
A first reading on your teamAt day 90, a short card asks your staff three questions. You see where things are working and where they're stuck.
How a search works

Five steps from open position to first day.

  1. I
    The Need

    We settle the role, the pay, the panel, and the timeline before anything is posted.

  2. II
    Getting the Word Out

    A posting written for mission-minded Catholic candidates, placed where they look.

  3. III
    Candidate Selection

    We screen every applicant. Your panel meets only the finalists, in one day whenever possible.

  4. IV
    The Offer

    Background check, a personal phone call, then the written offer.

  5. V
    Onboarding Begins

    Your new hire starts with a plan for the first 90 days.

See the full recruiting process →
How we carry a search

Prayer first. Then process.

Carried in prayer

Hiring for the Church is ministry.

Jill prays for each open position every week before the Blessed Sacrament. Every interview starts with prayer. And we remember that a search represents the Catholic Church. How a candidate is treated, hired or not, is a chance to evangelize.

Done properly

And it's run by the book.

Pax Ordo recruiting understands and follows employment law, diocesan norms and policies, and industry best practices.

Plain talk

When you shouldn't hire us.

We'd sooner tell you now than take a search that won't serve you.

You have time and good candidates.

If the role isn't urgent and strong people are already asking about it, run it yourself. Our Field Notes are free and may help.

Your leaders disagree about the role.

A search can't settle what the job is. Settle that first. We can help with that conversation, and it's a shorter one.

You want a warm body by Friday.

We're built for the right hire, and that takes a few weeks. A rushed hire usually costs more than the open seat does.

Free, with no strings

Start with something useful.

You don't have to hire us to get help.

Field Notes

What we're seeing in parishes and schools

Short articles on hero culture, role clarity, and keeping an institution steady through a change of pastor.

Read Field Notes →
30 minutes

A call about the role

Talk it through with someone who's hired for Catholic schools and parishes. You'll leave with a plan either way.

Request a call →
Beyond the hire

A good hire is where order starts.

A healthy staff knows who owns what, hears the truth kindly, and has someone to call when a people problem comes up. We help with that too.

The next step after a hire

Friction Finder

A short session with your whole staff. They name what's getting in the way of the work. You leave with the first things to fix and who owns each one.

Two hours, with no homework afterward. A fix can be something your staff stops doing. How Friction Finder works →

Interim HR Director
Cover the gap

Your HR person leaves, or you've never had one. We step in for a set period and keep hiring, onboarding, and people questions moving.

Learn more →
Employee lifecycle
From first day to last day

Onboarding, retention, employee listening, performance reviews, and separations handled with dignity.

Learn more →
Culture workshops
Sessions for your whole staff

Practical workshops on trust, who owns what, and how supervisors say the hard thing with care.

Learn more →
HR advice
An HR director on call

A monthly arrangement for parishes and schools without an HR person. Call when something comes up.

Learn more →
HR assessment
Know where you stand

A review of how you hire, onboard, review, and part ways with people, and a short report on what to fix first.

Learn more →
Client portal
Every search in one place

Clients get a login to follow each position and candidate, and a careers page of their own.

Client login →
100+People hired by our founder
Who you'd be working with

Jill Wollmer is the founder of Pax Ordo and has served as HR Director of a five-campus Catholic school system. She's hired well over 100 people, built onboarding and review systems from scratch, and trained supervisors to have the conversations most of us would sooner avoid.

She works from inside the Church's world. She knows what a pastor carries, what a finance council asks, and what a Catholic hire needs that a corporate recruiter won't think to ask about.

About Jill →

Pax Ordo Advisors is a registered LLC.

Parishes · Catholic schools · School systems · Diocesan offices · Catholic ministries

“Peace is the tranquility of order.”

St. Augustine, City of God

When does the empty seat start to hurt?

Tell us about the role. We'll be straight with you about how long it should take, what it will cost, and whether we're the right help.

Start a Conversation →